Finally, I think I’m starting to understand the president’s plan for health care. President Obama’s speech last night went a long way to reassure me about his plans. It sounds like I can get behind his plan. The fight isn’t over, though; Obama still has to get this plan through Congress.
President Obama mustered all the force of his famous eloquence – including a stirring tug at the bonds of friendship between Republican senators and their late Democratic colleague Edward Kennedy – to push the reset button on health care Wednesday night.
Casting himself in the political center and shedding his earlier technocratic style for a powerful appeal to “the American character,” Obama outlined in a nationally televised address to a joint session of Congress how everyone, insured and uninsured alike, small businesses and large, could gain from his proposals.
He sought to bridge the deep rift among Democrats over a public insurance option that threatens to send him and his party to a devastating defeat.
“We did not come to fear the future,” Obama said. “We came here to shape it.”
Seizing authorship for the first time of what the White House now calls “the Obama plan,” Obama made flexibility, not ultimatums, the order of the day and “stability and security” for all the mantra.
It’s still hugely expensive at $900 billion over 10 years, but it is necessary to have health care reform. Costs are rising too fast and too many people are uninsured to sit around doing nothing. I think everyone can agree on that, even if they can’t agree right now on how to get there. But that will come, especially if the debate is vigorous and respectful.
That brings me to Congressman Joe Wilson (R-SC) and his “you lie!” shout while the president was speaking. Wilson disrespected himself, his office, Congress as a whole, President Obama, and the office of the president of the United States. I feel disrespected as a result. There is no place for heckling the president during an address to a joint session of Congress. What was Wilson thinking?
From Dana Milbank’s Washington Sketch column:
As President Obama addressed a joint session of Congress on Wednesday night, the nation’s rapidly deteriorating discourse hit yet another low.
It happened at 8:40 pm, just after the president vowed to lawmakers that his health-care reform proposals would not provide benefits to illegal immigrants. As millions of Americans watched from home, Rep. Joe Wilson (R-S.C.) shouted at the president from his fifth-row seat: “You lie!”
Murmurs of “ooh” filled the stunned chamber. Nancy Pelosi’s chin dropped. Obama moved on to the next sentence in his speech, about how no federal money would be used to fund abortion. “Not true!” came another shout.
The national debate, already raw for years, had coarsened over the summer as town hall meetings across the country dissolved into protests about “death panels” and granny-killing. Guns were brought to Obama appearances. A pastor in Arizona said he was praying for Obama to die.
But even by that standard, there was something appalling about the display on the House floor for what was supposed to be a sacred ritual of American democracy: the nation watching while Cabinet members, lawmakers from both chambers and the diplomatic corps assembled.
Wilson was only the most flagrant. There was booing from House Republicans when the president caricatured a conservative argument by saying they would “leave individuals to buy health insurance on their own.” They hissed when he protested their “scare tactics.” They grumbled as they do in Britain’s House of Commons when Obama spoke of the “blizzard of charges and countercharges.”
When he asserted that “nothing in this plan will require you or your employer to change the coverage or the doctor you have,” there was scoffing and outright laughter on the GOP side. Rep. Jeb Hensarling (Tex.) shook his head in disbelief. Several Republicans shouted “What plan?” and Rep. Louis Gohmert (Tex.) waved at Obama a handwritten poster he made on a letter-size piece of paper: “WHAT PLAN?” Gohmert then took that down and replaced it with another handmade poster that said “WHAT BILL?”
The irony was that Obama had used his speech to offer a significant concession to Republicans and to break with liberals in his own party. There was a cool silence in the chamber as the president told “my progressive friends” that the “public option” they treasure as part of health-care reform could be sacrificed in favor of other ideas.
[snip]
When Obama addressed the charge that he plans “panels of bureaucrats with the power to kill off senior citizens,” someone on the GOP side shouted out “shame!” The president went on: “Such a charge would be laughable if it weren’t so cynical.” “Read the bill!” someone shouted back. Obama mentioned those who accuse him of a government takeover of health care. “It’s true,” someone shouted back.
The antics continued when Obama urged opponents to “come to me with a serious set of proposals.” About 20 Republican members raised copies of the GOP health-reform proposal over their heads. They raised their props again when Obama criticized those who think “it’s better politics to kill this plan than improve it.”
Even as Obama delivered a tribute to the late senator Ted Kennedy, Rep. Tom Price (R-Ga), a leader of House conservatives, perused his BlackBerry. Shortly before the speech ended, Rep. Patrick McHenry (R-N.C.) walked out to beat the rush.
Above all, though, was Wilson’s effrontery. From the reaction in the chamber — one Democrat could be heard calling for him to be thrown out — Wilson knew he had stepped in it. He shrugged, then consulted his BlackBerry. He puffed out his cheeks to exhale and licked his lips.
Toward the end of Obama’s speech, the text of which was handed out before the congressman’s outburst, was a fitting rebuke of the sort of behavior Wilson had just exhibited. When “we can no longer even engage in a civil conversation with each other over the things that truly matter,” Obama said, “we don’t merely lose our capacity to solve big challenges. We lose something essential about ourselves.”
As Obama spoke these words, Wilson twiddled his thumbs, then took his BlackBerry from its holster to consult it yet again. The speech ended, and, as his colleagues applauded, Wilson beat a hasty retreat.
An incensed White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel went up to GOP Reps. Roy Blunt (Mo.) and Paul Ryan (Wis.) to complain about the outburst. “No president has ever had that happen,” Emanuel said. “My advice is he apologize immediately. You know my number.”
Wilson did as Emanuel advised. After all that shouting, it’s a wonder he wasn’t too hoarse to place the call.
It doesn’t much matter to me that Wilson apologized. His behavior was loutish and had no place being directed to a president addressing a joint session of Congress. But then, he was in good company from the rest of the Republicans. The one bright side, as Joel Achenbach points out:
Politics is a game of momentum; the Republicans very likely surrendered it by trying to emulate the angriest of their constituents.
It’s fine to be angry, and it’s fine to disagree. But that doesn’t give anyone the excuse to heckle the president. I’ve called over and over for real ideas from the Republicans. Instead of that, we get more and more anger and vitriol. And the country suffers for that. I said it yesterday: It’s time to take a deep breath, remember that we’re Americans, and try — just try — to set aside some of the anger and do what’s best for the nation. I know that’s a lot to ask for from politicians. But the times demand it.
Recent Comments